Design and population Cohort study
Sexually
active women in natural post menopause, residents of Quindío (Colombia), who
consulted for vaginal discharge syndrome were included; in which the diagnosis
of bacterial vaginosis (BV) was made using the Amsel criteria and confirmed
with the Nugent score (Annex 1 and 2), in a private clinic, of third level of
complexity, reference center in the department from Quindío, and that serves
the population belonging to the contributory regime and the one subsidized by
the State in the social security system in Colombia; between May 1, 2013 and
April 30, 2016. Women who had received antibiotics during the last two weeks,
those who used a vaginal douche or referred sexual intercourse during the 24
hours prior to the check-up, not having received hormone replacement therapy in
the last six months, and data loss greater than 10% were excluded. A
consecutive sampling was done and all women who met the inclusion and exclusion
criteria were considered. Procedure Patients with a diagnosis of BV were
selected, based on the identification of the following codes of the
international classification of diseases (ICD10): N76.0-Acute vaginitis or
N76.1-Subacute vaginitis, in which the Amsel criteria and Nugent score for BV
were met. For women who met the selection criteria and agreed to participate in
the study, the study objectives were explained to them, and after signing the
informed consent, an Excel® 14.0 form was filled out, where the
sociodemographic characteristics were recorded, clinical symptoms and clinical
examination data. All the participants were evaluated by the main investigator;
Speculoscopy was also performed, in order to evaluate flow characteristics
(quantity, color, consistency and smell), and the presence of vulvovaginal signs
(vulva, vaginal walls and cervix), among others. The nature of their clinical
condition was explained to each patient, and intravaginal ovules of the
combination nifuratel 500 mg - nystatin 200,000 IU were offered as a
therapeutic option (every night at bedtime), for six (6) days, following the
scheme, who state that the combination of nifuratel 500 mg + nystatin 200,000
IU once a day is the best dose (in terms of risk / benefit ratio) [25].
Collection and transport of samples
Vaginal pH was measured in each participant
using a test strip (MQuant®), the amine test was performed with the application
of 10% potassium hydroxide drops (10% KOH) to a sample of vaginal discharge; A
sample of the vaginal discharge was taken with a cotton swab from the anterior
cul-de-sac and lateral walls of the vagina, which was spread on a microscope
slide with Gram stain in order to evaluate the presence of clue cells (guide)
and the Nugent score.
Intervention [9]
The ovule with the combination of nifuratel
500 mg + nystatin 200,000 IU was applied at night, at bedtime, for 6 days. The
treatment was delivered to each participant by a professional nurse in charge
for this purpose, without the intervention of the researcher. A group of three
nursing assistants were in charge of daily monitoring of each patient to ensure
that the drug was applied in the indicated way, while at the same time
investigating the presence of adverse reactions. Two (2) follow-ups were
conducted: one week (seven days after the therapy started), and one month
(thirty days after the therapy ended). In the first control, the absence or
presence of symptoms was evaluated, and the appearance of adverse reactions was
also investigated to assess safety. In the month's follow-up, the absence or
presence of symptoms was taken into consideration to evaluate the therapeutic
effect, as well as the Amsel criteria and the Nugent score in order to
establish the presence of recurrences. The findings of each of the women were
recorded in each control. The follow-up program was complemented with a
communication telephone line, through which the group of nursing assistants
monitored the application of the therapy on a daily basis and inquired about
the presence of any adverse reaction. The procedures for data collection, completion
and storage of information were standardized by training the nursing staff who
supported the study by the main investigator. Adverse reactions were evaluated
through the application of a survey, to each patient, in each of the controls;
survey prepared by the research team; where the class, frequency and severity
of each adverse reaction and the etiological role of the treatment were
questioned.
Variables measured
Sociodemographic (age, ethnicity, level of
education, marital status, socio-economic stratum, occupation, affiliation to
the general health social security system, religion, area of residence),
weight, height, BMI; time spent with a partner, age of menopause, evolution of
time of menopause; habits (alcohol intake, smoking, sedentary lifestyle),
medical history, sexual behavior variables (masturbation, oral sex, intercourse
–vaginal or anal–, use of erotic toys, frequency of monthly sexual relations);
history of bacterial vaginosis in the last year, incomplete treatment in
episodes of previous bacterial vaginosis; presence or absence of the symptoms
of bacterial vaginosis and adverse reactions. The Amsel criteria and the Nugent
score were also evaluated.
Statistical analysis
Absolute and relative frequencies were
calculated for the qualitative variables; in the quantitative variables,
measures of central tendency (mean, median) and dispersion (standard deviation,
percentiles, minimum value, maximum value and range) were used. The statistical
analysis was done with the Epi Info® 7.2 programs. And Stata® 15.1.
Ethical aspects
The study was approved by the Ethics Committee
of the participating institution. The requirements for medical research on
human beings established in the Declaration of Helsinki and with Resolution
8430 of 1993 were met, which establishes the scientific, technical and
administrative standards for health research. All participants signed the
informed consent to enter the study. The confidentiality of the information was
guaranteed.
Results
During the follow-up
period, 3,157 women with bacterial vaginosis were treated at the institution,
of which 429 (13.58%) met the inclusion criteria; 147 (34.26%) were excluded
for having received antibiotics in the last two weeks, 135 (31.46%) for having
used a vaginal douche, 49 (11.42%) because they reported sexual intercourse
during the previous 24 hours and 41 (9.55%) for data loss greater than 10%. In
the end, a sample of 57 patients was obtained. The mean age of the participants
was 57.36 ± 4.28 years. 87.71% were of urban origin, 89.47% belonged to the
contributory insurance scheme and 92.98% were Catholic. Table 1 describes the
sociodemographic characteristics of the population (Table 1).
Table
1: Sociodemographic characteristics of women
with bacterial vaginosis, in Quindío, 2013-2016.
|
Variable and categories
|
n(%)
|
|
Age: X ± SD years
|
57,36 ± 4,28
|
|
Age of partner: X ± SD years
|
59,61 ± 4,38
|
|
Weight: X ± SD Kg
|
67,95 ± 8,24
|
|
Height: X ± SD Cms
|
157,39 ± 4,82
|
|
BMI: X ± SD
|
27,63 ± 5,41
|
|
Race
|
|
White
|
37 (64.91%)
|
|
Indigenous
|
7 (12.28%)
|
|
Afro Colombian %
|
13 (22.8 %)
|
|
Civil Status
|
|
Married %
|
24 (42.1%)
|
|
Common Law
|
14 (24.56%)
|
|
Single
|
10 (17.54%)
|
|
Widows
|
9 (15.78%)
|
|
Occupation
|
|
Housewives
|
34 (59.64%)
|
|
Employed
|
17 (29.82%)
|
|
Retired
|
6 (10.52%)
|
|
Socioeconomic status
|
|
High
|
15 (26.31%)
|
|
Middle
|
36 (63.15%)
|
|
Low
|
6 (10.52%)
|
|
Educational level
|
|
Primary
|
3 (5.26%)
|
|
Secondary
|
18 (31.57%)
|
|
Technical
|
21 (36.84%)
|
|
Professionals
|
15 (26.31%)
|
The
mean age of menopause was 48.93 ± 5.71 years, with a mean duration of menopause
of 8.95 ± 4.73 years. The time of living together as a couple was 16.27 ± 5.92
years. Alcohol intake was present in 68.42% of the women. 19.29% smoked, with a
median consumption of 3 cigarettes per day (range between 3 and 9). Sedentary
lifestyle was observed in 77.19%. In the medical history, it was observed that
40.35% had hypertension, 36.84% had dyslipidemia, 15.78% hypothyroidism, and
8.25% had type 2 diabetes. 8.77% had a history of breast cancer, and 12.28% had
morbid obesity. A history of bacterial vaginosis in the last year was detected
in 21.05% (n = 12/57) of the women; of which eight stated that they had not
completed the treatment. In relation to the variables of sexual behaviour,
masturbation was an experience barely explored by 14.03% of the women. Oral sex
was the preferred sexual practice for 84.21%. Vaginal intercourse was practiced
by 100%, while anal was reported by 12.28%. The frequency of monthly sexual intercourse
yielded a median of 2 (range between 0 and 5). The use of erotic toys was
detected in 22.8% of the participants. Upon entry to the study, 100% of the
women were symptomatic. The symptoms reported by the patients, in order of
frequency, are detailed in Table 2; being the grayish-white adherent discharge
(91.22%) the most frequent, followed by bad odor (85.96%) and vaginal burning
(75.43%). 75.43% (n = 43/57) presented four or fewer symptoms, 19.29% (n =
11/57) five, and 5.26% (n = 3/57) six or more symptoms; with a median of 4
(range between 3 and> 6) (Table 2).
Table 2: Symptoms of
postmenopausal women with bacterial vaginosis, in Quindío, 2013–2016.
|
Symptoms
|
n
(%)
|
|
Bad
vaginal odor
|
49
(85.96%)
|
|
Clue
cells (guide)
|
34
(59.64%)
|
|
Dysuria
|
5
(8.77%)
|
|
Grayish-white
adherent discharge
|
52
(91.22%)
|
|
pH
>4,5
|
41
(71.92%)
|
|
Vaginal
burning
|
43
(75.43%)
|
|
Vaginal
irritation
|
6
(10.52%)
|
|
Vaginal
itching
|
14
(24.56%)
|
At one week of follow-up, the positive effect
of the combination of nifuratel 500 mg + nystatin 200,000 IU was evident when
the absence of symptoms was observed in 94.73% (n = 54/57) of the participants;
presenting a total of 3 therapeutic failures (n = 3/57 = 5.26%), of which two
were diabetic and one had morbid obesity. At one month of follow-up, 89.47% (n
= 51/57) of the patients reported absence of symptoms, which was demonstrated
with the Amsel criteria and confirmed with a median Nugent score of 3; In 5.26%
there was a recurrence of the infection, which added to 5.26% of therapeutic
failure, finally reported 10.52% (n = 6/57) of therapeutic failure; of which
three were diabetic, two were morbidly obese and one was a sex worker. The
initial median in the Nugent score was 8 (range between 7 and 10), decreasing
to 3 (range between 0 and 7) at one month of follow-up. In none of the patients
there were adverse reactions, therefore, there was no need to discontinue the
medication; there was also no loss to follow up.